Love Island USA: 10 Most Popular Contestants, Ranked By Instagram Followers (2024)

The island of love where you either leave in love, as a meme, or with a huge Instagram following, it is no secret that Love Island has dominated most international TV screens every summer, with the British show having spin-offs in multiple countries including the USA. The notorious dating show introduced some of the most interesting and outrageous personalities to the world of reality TV.

RELATED:8 Ways Love Island USA Is Better Than The UK Version

Whether it's Caro's baby voice, Cely's infectious laugh, or Jeremy's solo dance moves in front of the mirror,Love Island USA has definitely given fans a range of cast members that have been incredibly popular on both the big screen and the slightly smaller screen of Instagram, whether it's for all theright or wrong reasons.

Mackenzie (Season 2): 324K Followers

Mackenzie was a blonde bombshell from day one ofher stay in the villa, but it was her relationship with Connor that skyrocketed her popularity, which wasn't always for the right reasons.

Mackenzie was quick to be labeled Love Island's most unpopular contestant of season 2when she stormed away from the group multiple times, causing tension between her and Connor. Even Laurenwas scared to approachher after the public voted for Connor to go on a date with the new bombshell. Mackenzie definitely left her mark on the villa, which saw her Instagram following hit a whopping 324K.

Aissata (Season 1) 348K Followers

Aissata entered the villa in season 1 as a latecomer, but her late entrance didn't stop her from being a popular season 1 cast member.She hadfans' hearts from day one with her glamorous appearance and bubbly personality, which caught fellow cast member, Yamen's, eye.

Aissata and Yamen shared a mutual love of zodiac signs for several episodes, but by episode 19 they were both dumped. However, her popularity continued offscreen, with her gaining 349,000 followers.

Cashay (Season 3) 363K Followers

Cashay was easily one of the most likable cast members of Love Island USAseason 3, with her confidence seeing her be loud and proud about self-love. Cashay was a firm fan favorite, which is why fans were left shocked when she was dramatically eliminated after putting her faith in Chris, who chose Alana instead.

Following her departure, Cashay's Instagram following grew and she soon rekindled with her former flame from the villa, Cinco, who often makes an appearance on her Instagram page, much to the excitement of her 363,000 followers.

Kyra (Season 1) 366K Followers

Kyra from season 1, not to be confused with season 2 Kyra, was possibly the most flirtatious character of her season and shecoupledup with Cashel on day 2. Before being chosen by Kyra, Cashel had developed a bond with Caro, but was soon drawn in by Kyra, which saw the couple develop feelings for each other.

RELATED:10 Best Shows Like Love Island

However, Kyra had met her match, as Cashel was increasingly flirty with other cast members. Kyra expressed her attraction to Emily but soon gravitated back to Cashel, and was surprised to be dumped. But despite the pair no longer being together, Kyra has a growing Instagram following of 336,000.

Justine (Season 2) 424K Followers

Justine didn't just find love in the villa but also friendship with fellow islander, Cely, who became a well-liked third wheel in Justine's relationship with Caleb. The pair's infectious laughter made season 2 a positive viewing experience, resulting in Justine winning the show and Cely coming runner up.

Justine's relationship with both Cely and Caleb was addictive to watch. Her ability to be rational and give sound advice to other islanders madeher one of the most likable cast members, highlighted by her 425K followers on Instagram.

Cely (Season 2) 477K Followers

Cely was the chaoticcontestantLove Island USAseason two needed with her loud and bubbly personality bagging her both a man and a best friend. Cely was known for subjecting all islanders to her hilarious pranks, including her prime targets, Justine and Johnny. She even woke the islanders up every morning with words of encouragement which she later needed herself.

Following Johnny's mini-break to Casa Amor, Cely was left heartbroken. But the pair soon regrouped and dated for several months after leaving the show. Cely'sunique energyled to an Instagram following of 477K and later to her own YouTube channel.

Johnny (Season 2) 495K Following

Johnny gained popularity quickly in the show when he coupled up with Cely, leading to the most watchable friendship group consisting of him, Cely, Justine, Caleb. The group of four made it to the finals, but that doesn't mean there weren't bumps along the way.

RELATED:10 Funniest Non-Romantic Moments Of Love Island's Season 3

His Casa Amor escapades led to the downfall of both his relationship and friendship group, but this soon resolved itself whenhe rightfully apologized and proved his loyalty. Johnny now has an Instagram following of almost 500K, where he shows off his fitness regime.

Leslie (Season 3) 510K Followers

Leslie entered the villa after the OG Love Island girls left for Casa Amor. And her entrance saw her develop a relationship with Korey before moving on to Cinco, but her experience was cut short when her departure from the show was announced.

Leslie was a controversial islander, with many sharing their dislike for her after an argument with Genevieve, Leslie and the group erupted. After leaving the show, Leslie said that her shocking departure had nothing to do with anyone in the villa and has since earned 510K followers on Instagram.

Caro (Season 1) 552K Followers

Caro's outlandish personality paved the way for her being crowned one of the funniest contestants in Love Island USA history. Shejoined the cast on day one and made it to the final four alongside partner Ray Gantt, who she later split with on the outside world in 2020.

It was not only her humor that made Love Island history but also her baby voice that left fans laughing and led to her being an adored islander, made obvious through her following of 552K and popular YouTube channel, where she doesn't hide her contagious personality.

Kaitlynn (Season 2) 1M Followers

Kaitlynn has a huge following fora cast member with such a shortstint in the village. She Arrived on day one and later exited the villa five days later when she did not recouple. However,she didn't leave the villa before being involved in some drama.

On the first night, the islanders played a game which saw Tre dared to kiss an islander he wanted to know more about, leading to him kissing Kaitlynn in front of Carrington. Unfortunately, Tre decided to couple up with Justine, which meant Kaitlynn had to say goodbye to the villa early on in the season. Her time in the villa didn't go unnoticed, though,and she now has a grand following of 1 million.

NEXT:10 Things Love Island USA Can Learn From The UK Version

Love Island USA: 10 Most Popular Contestants, Ranked By Instagram Followers (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ouida Strosin DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6247

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ouida Strosin DO

Birthday: 1995-04-27

Address: Suite 927 930 Kilback Radial, Candidaville, TN 87795

Phone: +8561498978366

Job: Legacy Manufacturing Specialist

Hobby: Singing, Mountain biking, Water sports, Water sports, Taxidermy, Polo, Pet

Introduction: My name is Ouida Strosin DO, I am a precious, combative, spotless, modern, spotless, beautiful, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.